To understand the nationality issue of surrogate babies, we first need to master the two basic principles of nationality in international law. These two principles exist side by side in the legislation of various countries around the world, and are often cross-applied, forming nationality systems with unique characteristics in each country.
Jus soli, Latin for "right to the land", refers to the determination of nationality based on the territorial ownership of the place where one was born. Any individual born within the territory of that country, regardless of the nationality of his or her parents, may acquire the nationality of that country in accordance with the law. The United States and Canada are the most typical jus soli countries in the world, and Colombia also adopts this principle.
Jus sanguinis, which means "right of blood" in Latin, refers to the determination of the nationality of children based on the nationality of the parents (or one of them), regardless of the place of birth. Most Eurasian countries—including China, Kyrgyzstan, and Georgia—have jus sanguinis as the main principle.
Article 5 of Kyrgyzstan’s Citizenship Law stipulates that if a child born in Kyrgyzstan has both parents who are foreign citizens, the child will not automatically acquire Kyrgyz nationality, and his or her nationality will be determined by the law of the parents’ nationality. Article 12 of Georgia’s Citizenship Law also has similar provisions.
Some countries adopt both principles at the same time, or make exceptions for specific circumstances. For example, in addition to the jus soli doctrine, the United States also provides a blood nationality transmission mechanism for children of U.S. citizens born abroad through Section 301 of the Immigration and Nationality Act. This mixed application may trigger legal disputes over dual nationality in the context of surrogacy.
Article 3 of China’s Nationality Law clearly stipulates that dual nationality of Chinese citizens is not recognized. This means that if a surrogate baby is born in the United States and automatically acquires U.S. nationality, China will not legally recognize the child as having Chinese nationality; if the family wants the child to return to China as a Chinese citizen, they usually need to give up the U.S. nationality first or deal with household registration issues separately after entering the country as a U.S. citizen.
"The nationality issue is not an administrative procedure, but a fundamental legal arrangement related to a child's future identity and rights protection. Before signing a surrogacy contract, the client must fully evaluate the nationality rules of the destination country and its impact on the child's long-term life with a legal advisor."===== Chapter 2 =====
——The Hague Conference on Private International Law (HCCH) "Research Report on Parent-Child Relationship and International Surrogacy Issues", 2023
KyrgyzstanKyrgyzstan is currently one of the most important destinations for Chinese-speaking surrogacy families, and the legality of surrogacy is clearly established in accordance with Article 104 of the Citizen Health Protection Law. On issues of nationality and parental rights, Kyrgyzstan adopts a legal stance that is extremely friendly to the client.
Parental rights recognition mechanism:According to Article 56 of Kyrgyzstan’s Marriage and Family Code, the client (genetic parents) in the surrogacy contract can directly register as the legal parent after the child is born, and the surrogate mother clearly gives up her parental rights in the contract. In practice, the hospital birth certificate (Свидетельство о рождении) can be issued directly in the name of the client without the need for court confirmation procedures. This is one of the most important legal advantages of surrogacy in Kyrgyzstan.
Nationality acquisition path:Since Kyrgyzstan adopts jus sanguinis, the children of the foreign client will not automatically acquire Kyrgyz nationality. After the child is born, the entrusting party takes the Kyrgyz birth certificate (issued in the name of the entrusting party) to the Chinese Embassy in Kyrgyzstan to apply for the child’s Chinese travel document (passport). The consulate usually requires a DNA paternity test report to verify blood relationship, and will issue a Chinese passport to the child after passing the review.
georgiaArticle 1431 of the Civil Code of Georgia clearly stipulates that the client couple in the surrogacy contract are the legal parents of the child, and the surrogate mother has no right to assert parental rights. Georgia only allows married heterosexual couples to entrust surrogacy, which is one of the main differences between it and Kyrgyzstan.
Parental rights recognition mechanism:Similar to Kyrgyzstan, Georgia can also directly register the entrusting party as the parent in the birth certificate without the need for court procedures. However, the Ministry of Health of Georgia requires that the surrogacy contract must be notarized, and the client couple must provide a marriage certificate (subject to apostille or consular certification) as a prerequisite material.
Nationality acquisition path:Georgia is also a jus sanguinis country, and children of foreign clients do not obtain Georgian citizenship. After the child is born, go to the Chinese Embassy in Georgia to apply for a passport with the Georgian birth certificate (which must be stamped with the Apostille seal of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs). Georgia is a member state of the Hague Convention. Apostille authentication of its public documents is directly accepted in most countries, and the document link is relatively simple.
USAThe United States is the most legally protected surrogacy destination in the world, but it is also the most expensive option. On the issue of nationality, the jus soli doctrine directly confers U.S. citizenship to children born in the United States. This advantage also brings unique dual citizenship challenges for Chinese families.
Parental rights recognition mechanism:The determination of paternity for surrogacy in the United States varies from state to state. Surrogacy-friendly states such as California, Nevada, and Washington State allow the client to obtain a "Pre-Birth Order (PBO)" through the court before the child is born, and the child's birth certificate is directly registered in the name of the client. States such as Texas and Illinois usually complete the determination through a "Post-Birth Order" after birth. A surrogacy contract in the United States must be drafted by a licensed family law attorney in each state and signed by both parties, and is extremely legally binding.
Nationality acquisition path:The child acquires U.S. citizenship upon birth and can apply for a U.S. passport. For families who plan to have their children live as Chinese citizens, there are two main ways to deal with it: one is to keep the U.S. passport, and the child enters China as a U.S. citizen and lives with the U.S. passport for a long time; the other is not to actively declare to the Chinese authorities before the child reaches adulthood, and handle the household registration through adoption in China or special settlement procedures (the legal risk is high and the guidance of a professional lawyer is required). Since Chinese law does not recognize dual nationality, most Chinese families who choose surrogacy in the United States prefer to retain their children's U.S. citizenship and make their own nationality choices when they reach adulthood.
ColombiaThe legal framework of surrogacy in Colombia mainly relies on the jurisprudence of the Constitutional Court rather than written legislation. Its core basis is the Colombian Constitutional Court’s 2009 Judgment No. T-968, which confirmed the constitutionality of the surrogacy contract and protected the parental rights of the client. Colombia has become one of the fastest growing options among mid-cost surrogacy destinations in recent years.
Parental rights recognition mechanism:Colombia currently has no specific surrogacy legislation, and determination of paternity relies on notarized agreements and birth registration practices. In major cities such as Bogota and Medellin, after the surrogacy contract is notarized, the hospital can register the client as the parent on the birth certificate based on the notarized contract. However, civil registration officials in some areas have insufficient knowledge of surrogacy contracts, and there is a risk that additional legal procedures will be required. It is recommended that the birth be completed in a city with rich surrogacy experience.
Nationality acquisition path:Article 96 of the Colombian Constitution stipulates that all persons born in Colombian territory, regardless of the nationality of their parents, are Colombian citizens (jus soli principle). This means that a surrogate baby born in Colombia will automatically acquire Colombian citizenship. Similar to the situation in the United States, Chinese families usually choose to: return to China with a Colombian passport (the child lives in China long-term as a foreign citizen); or try to apply for a Chinese passport for the child through the Chinese Embassy in Colombia certification process (DNA paternity testing and a complete document chain are required).
"In the absence of a unified international treaty, the issues of nationality and parental rights in international surrogacy are still in the decentralized stage of judicial practice in various countries. The conflict between the laws of each destination country and the receiving country requires the client to conduct a systematic bilateral legal assessment before starting the project."===== Chapter 3 =====
——The Hague Conference on Private International Law (HCCH) "Transnational Surrogacy Arrangements and the Best Interests of the Child" Report, 2023
No matter in which country the surrogacy is completed, the document preparation and processing process involved in the return of the child to the country are the most important aspects of the entire project that require advance planning. The following uses the Kyrgyzstan route most commonly chosen by Chinese-speaking clients as the main reference, and notes the differences between countries.
After the surrogate baby is born, the hospital will issue a birth certificate within 24-72 hours (document in Russian for Kyrgyzstan, Georgian and English for Georgia, English for the United States, and Spanish for Colombia). In Kyrgyzstan and Georgia, the birth certificate is registered directly in the name of the client; in the United States, depending on the circumstances of the state and the time of the parental authority order, the birth certificate may be issued in the name of the surrogate mother and then changed, or directly in the name of the client (in the case of a pre-existing parental order).
For countries that have joined the Hague Convention (1961 Convention on the Abolition of the Requirement for Authentication of Foreign Public Documents), their official documents must be "Apostille" before they can be used in other member states without further consular authentication. Kyrgyzstan, Georgia, the United States, and Colombia are all members of the Hague Convention; mainland China officially joined the Convention on November 7, 2023. This historic change has significantly simplified the certification process for the above-mentioned national documents entering China.
Before China joined the Hague Convention, documents had to be "consularly authenticated" (double authentication) before they could be used in China, and the process was more cumbersome. Starting from November 2023, overseas official documents holding the Apostille seal will have direct effect in China, eliminating the previous steps of certification by Chinese embassies abroad, and greatly shortening the preparation period for return documents (usually compressed from 3-6 months to 1-2 months).
Before issuing a Chinese passport to a surrogate baby, the Chinese embassy in each destination country usually requires a DNA paternity test report issued by an accredited institution to verify the biological parentage between the child and the applicant.
After preparing all the documents, the client takes the child to the Chinese embassy (consulate) in the destination country to apply for a Chinese passport. Documents typically required include:
The embassy review cycle is usually 4-8 weeks. In some cases, approval by the entry-exit management department of the domestic public security bureau is required, which may be extended to 12 weeks. It is recommended that the client make an appointment with the embassy in advance and reserve enough time to accompany the child in the destination country.
If a child enters China with a Chinese passport, he or she is a Chinese citizen and does not need to apply for a visa. However, it should be noted that if the child also holds a passport of the country of birth (such as a U.S. passport or a Colombian passport), he must use a Chinese passport when entering China and is not allowed to enter with a foreign passport (which will cause China to identify him as a foreign citizen and increase the difficulty of subsequent settlement).
===== Chapter 4 =====After the child enters the country with a Chinese passport, the next important step is to apply for household registration (settlement) in China. This is one of the most Chinese-specific and most underestimated legal challenges in the entire surrogacy project.
China’s Household Registration Regulations (promulgated in 1958 and revised several times) stipulate that Chinese citizens must register their household registration at the place of household registration. For children of Chinese citizens born abroad, they usually need to apply for birth registration with the following materials:
Although children holding Chinese passports are legally entitled to settle in China, there are still many uncertainties in practice. The policy implementation standards of local police stations are not uniform. The household registration police in some areas are not familiar with the surrogacy situation and may require materials that cannot be provided (such as a birth medical certificate issued by a domestic hospital in China), or refuse to accept the application on the grounds that the policy is not clear yet.
At present, the effective settlement paths proven by surrogacy family practice are as follows:
Path One: Standard Overseas Birth Registration Path
With the birth certificate (Apostille certified version), DNA paternity test report, Chinese passport and other materials, go directly to the police station where the parents are registered to apply for household registration. This is the most legal and direct path, and its success depends largely on the policy implementation of the local police station and the awareness level of the staff. It is recommended to entrust a lawyer to pre-communicate with the local police station before settling in.
Path 2: Coordination through the Exit and Entry Administration Department of the Public Security Bureau
If the front-line window of the police station refuses to accept the application, you can apply for coordination with the entry-exit management department of the higher-level Public Security Bureau, explaining that the child is a Chinese citizen holding a Chinese passport, and requesting that it be handled in accordance with the standard procedures for children of Chinese citizens born abroad. This path has a higher success rate, but it takes longer (usually 3-9 months).
Path 3: Settling down after the court confirms parental rights
In a few cases, the client chooses to go through civil litigation or confirmation litigation in China. The court will issue a ruling confirming the parent-child relationship, and then go to the police station with the ruling to handle settlement. This path takes the longest (may take 1-2 years), but has the strongest legal effect and is suitable for use when other paths are blocked.
Statelessness is when a person is not considered a citizen of any country. In the surrogacy scenario, if the country of birth refuses to grant nationality to the child (for example, the country of birth explicitly adopts jus sanguinis and the client is a foreigner), and the country of the client (such as China) cannot complete nationality confirmation, the child may face statelessness.
The following situations may lead to the risk of statelessness:
As mentioned before, Chinese law does not recognize dual nationality. For surrogate babies born in jus soli countries (the United States, Colombia), they automatically acquire the nationality of the country of birth. If the client also applies for a Chinese passport for the child, the child is actually in a state of "de facto dual nationality", but this is not recognized by Chinese law.
In practice, most families deal with this:
After the child is born and before a Chinese passport is issued, it is sometimes necessary to use a travel document issued by the country of birth. The following are the specific arrangements for each destination:
| destination country | Transitional travel documents | Validity period | This can be used to enter China |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kyrgyzstan | Usually no need (if the child is of Chinese nationality, apply for a Chinese passport directly) | —— | Chinese passport entry |
| georgia | Usually no need (if the child is of Chinese nationality, apply for a Chinese passport directly) | —— | Chinese passport entry |
| USA | U.S. passport (domestic-based, automatically obtained) | 5 years (minor) | Entering the country as a foreigner (visa required or visa-free qualification) will not affect subsequent settlement |
| Colombia | Colombian passport or Colombian resident card | 5 years | Entering as a foreigner (with a valid visa or foreigner’s residence permit) |
In some countries where the legal validity of surrogacy contracts is unclear, there is a legal risk of the surrogate mother later regretting and claiming parental rights. This situation is extremely rare in Kyrgyzstan and Georgia where the legal framework is complete (because the birth certificate has been registered directly in the name of the entrusting party), but the risk is higher in countries where the law is not yet complete (such as some Asian or African countries).
"The actual enforcement effect of the surrogate mother's relinquishment of parental rights clause in the surrogacy contract depends on the recognition of the surrogacy contract by the legal system of the destination country. Choosing a country with mature legislation or stable judicial practice is a fundamental strategy to avoid this risk."===== Chapter 6: Comparison Table =====
——IFFS (International Federation of Fertility Societies) "Global Assisted Reproduction Survey Report 2023"
| Dimensions | Kyrgyzstan | georgia | USA | Colombia |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| nationality principle | jus sanguinis | jus sanguinis | Birthplaceism | Birthplaceism |
| Does the child obtain local nationality? | No (children of foreign parents do not obtain it automatically) | No (children of foreign parents do not obtain it automatically) | Yes (automatically acquires U.S. citizenship) | Yes (automatically obtains Colombian citizenship) |
| Birth certificate registration method | Register directly in the name of the entrusting party | Register directly in the name of the entrusting party | Depending on the circumstances of the parental rights order, it can be changed in advance or afterwards. | Usually in the name of the entrusting party, in a few cases supplementary procedures are required |
| Need confirmation of parental authority from the court? | Usually not required | Usually not required | Depends on state law, some states require | Depending on the actual situation, there may be occasional needs |
| How difficult is it to apply for a Chinese passport? | Low (clear lineage, mature process) | Low (clear process) | High (involving dual nationality processing) | China (need to deal with Colombian nationality issue) |
| Apostille certification applicable | Yes (has joined the Convention) | Yes (has joined the Convention) | Yes (has joined the Convention) | Yes (has joined the Convention) |
| Difficulty of settling in China | Medium (requires DNA identification, implementation varies from place to place) | Center (same as left) | High (involving complex processing of dual nationality) | High (involving Colombian nationality, the process is more complicated) |
| Suitable for the crowd | Married couples, unmarried couples, single men (depending on institution) | Married heterosexual couples (legal restrictions) | All types of principals (subject to state law) | Mainly married couples (recommended) |
| The time required from birth until the child holds a valid travel document | About 2-4 months | About 2-3 months | 1-2 months for US passport; 3-12 months for Chinese passport depending on the situation | Colombian passport takes 1-2 months; Chinese passport takes about 3-6 months |
In order to help the client systematically manage the document preparation work, the following provides a complete list of documents, mainly the Kyrgyzstan route, and explains the purpose and precautions of each document.
| stage | Required documents | Handling agency | Estimated time |
|---|---|---|---|
| after child is born | Original birth certificate (more than 3 copies) | Hospital/Civil Affairs Registration Authority | 1-3 working days |
| Document authentication | Apostille of birth certificate | Certification Office of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Kyrgyzstan | 3-7 working days |
| Document translation | Birth certificate translated into Chinese (a translation agency recognized by the embassy is required) | Translation agency recognized by the Embassy in Kyrgyzstan | 3-5 working days |
| DNA identification | paternity test report | Appraisal institution recognized by the Embassy in Kyrgyzstan | 7-15 working days |
| Passport application | Chinese passport application form, photos, full set of certification documents | Chinese Embassy in Kyrgyzstan | 4-8 weeks |
| Entry preparation | The child’s Chinese passport, the entrusting party’s passport, birth certificate and certified copy | —— | —— |
| Domestic settlement | Household registration application materials (see section 4.1 above) | Police station at the place of residence | 1 month to several years (depending on the region) |
Based on years of practical experience in serving Chinese surrogacy families, FS Global Ferticare has summarized the following key planning suggestions for the client’s reference before launching the project:
The assessment of nationality and settlement issues cannot begin after the child is born. It is recommended that the client communicate with the following professionals at least 12 months in advance before selecting a surrogacy destination country:
Among all available destinations, give priority to countries (Kyrgyzstan, Georgia) that can directly register the entrusting party as the parent on the birth certificate. This can fundamentally avoid risks such as surrogate mother regret and parental rights disputes, and greatly simplify the subsequent nationality and passport application process.
According to the above document process, the necessary stay time of the entrusting party in the destination country is usually:
All legal documents generated throughout the entire surrogacy project—surrogacy contracts, medical records, birth certificates, DNA tests, paternity orders, certification documents—should be kept in a safe place, with originals and multiple notarized copies. These documents are not only the basic materials for the child's passport and settlement, but may also be required for the child's future education, inheritance, exit, etc. It is recommended to encrypt storage after electronic scanning and to maintain at least two geographically separated physical backups.
The surrogacy laws of each destination country, the passport review policy of the Chinese embassy, and China’s domestic settlement policy may change at any time. It is recommended that the client maintain close communication with the professional team, keep abreast of the latest policy trends, and avoid misdirection of document preparation due to policy changes.
Need a professional evaluation based on your specific situation?
← Return to Knowledge Center | Free consultation with our professional consultants
References and authoritative sources:
The content of this article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or medical advice. Please consult a licensed professional for specific circumstances.