Surrogacy, a reproductive arrangement in which a third-party woman (surrogate mother) conceives and gives birth to the client (often called the "intended parents" or "the client"), has gradually developed around the world since the 1980s. With the maturity of assisted reproductive technology (ART), especially the popularization of in vitro fertilization (IVF) technology and embryo freezing technology, surrogacy has moved from ethical discussions to practical needs.
However, the differences between countries on surrogacy legislation are extremely significant. This disagreement reflects the profound differences between countries in core values such as bioethics, women's rights, identification of family structure, and the principle of children's best interests.
According to the International Federation of Fertility Societies (IFFS)"2023 Global Assisted Reproduction Regulatory Survey Report"(IFFS Surveillance 2023), a survey of 104 countries around the world shows:
For overseas Chinese clients, there is currently no legislation legalizing surrogacy in mainland China, and the former National Health and Family Planning Commission explicitly prohibited medical institutions from providing surrogacy services. Therefore, families who need surrogacy can only choose to go to countries where the law clearly allows it to complete this process.
Before discussing the legislation of various countries in depth, it is necessary to clarify the basic classification framework of surrogacy laws:
In addition to basic medical expenses and pregnancy care expenses, surrogate mothers can also receive additional compensation. This is the most common form of overseas surrogacy. Countries that allow commercial surrogacy have usually established relatively complete legal protection systems and clearly stipulated the rights and obligations of all parties.
The surrogate mother can only receive compensation for actual expenses directly related to the pregnancy (such as medical expenses, lost work wages) and no additional financial remuneration. Represented by the United Kingdom, Canada, and Australia, it usually requires an existing emotional connection with the surrogate mother (such as relatives, friends), the operation threshold is high, and the actual feasibility is limited.
This includes countries with explicit legislation prohibiting it, as well as "grey zone" countries with neither authorization nor prohibition. The risk of the latter is that even if surrogacy is completed, there may be significant legal obstacles in aspects such as confirmation of parental rights, birth registration, and exit.
Core legal basis:Article 55 of the "Kyrgyzstan Health Care Law" and relevant provisions of the "Family Code" clearly give the client the parental rights after the child is born. The surrogate mother voluntarily gives up her parental rights after signing the surrogacy agreement without going through additional court adoption procedures.
Important legislative nodes:The "Assisted Reproductive Technology Specifications" were revised in 2016 to further clarify the legal effect of the surrogacy contract and the obligations of all parties; in 2022, the relevant health regulations will be updated again, strengthening the qualification requirements and supervision mechanism of surrogacy agencies.
The client requires:
Surrogate mother requirements (legal requirements):
Mechanism for establishing parental rights:According to the current laws of Kyrgyzstan, the client becomes the legal parent after the child is born, and there is no need to go through secondary legal procedures. This mechanism is an important differentiator from many other surrogacy destinations.
Kyrgyzstan’s surrogacy market has experienced significant formalization over the past decade. Government health departments have become increasingly strict in supervising surrogacy agencies, requiring agencies to have formal IVF qualification certification and undergo regular medical supervision and inspections.
For Chinese clients, Kyrgyzstan’s main advantages are: relatively close geographical location (the flight distance is about 4-5 hours), relatively reasonable costs (usually in the range of 300,000-500,000 yuan, including full medical and legal services), and a relatively mature Chinese service system.
Core legal basis:Article 143 of the "Georgia Health Protection Law" clearly allows surrogacy, and at the same time gives the client (limited to heterosexual married couples) direct parental rights when the child is born, and the surrogate mother's name does not appear on the birth certificate.
Client restrictions:
Legal advantages:
It is worth noting that Georgia has experienced certain political instability in recent years, and some European countries have listed Georgia as a travel warning area. For clients who are considering surrogacy in Georgia, it is recommended to pay close attention to the local political situation and fully understand the stability and compliance status of medical institutions.
The cost of surrogacy in Georgia is usually in the range of 350,000-550,000 yuan (including complete services), which is similar to Kyrgyzstan. However, in recent years, the price has fluctuated due to changes in the rupee exchange rate and local prices.
Core legal basis:The Colombian Constitutional Court passed ruling T-968 in 2009, officially confirming the legal validity of the surrogacy agreement. Since then, relevant judgments of the Supreme Court have further improved the rights protection mechanism for both parties to surrogacy. In 2020, Colombia promulgated a more systematic regulatory framework for assisted reproductive technology.
Important features:
Things to note:Colombia's surrogacy legislation is still in the evolutionary stage, and special legislation has not yet been fully systematized, and some provisions rely on judicial interpretation. When choosing a Colombian surrogacy agency, it is recommended to focus on checking the professional qualifications of its legal team and the success rate of past cases.
Core legal basis:Article 54 of the Kazakhstan Marriage and Family Code clearly allows surrogacy and stipulates that the client automatically obtains legal parental rights when the child is born. The Health Law of Kazakhstan also provides normative provisions on the application of assisted reproductive technology.
Client conditions:
Market status:Astana (formerly Nur-Sultan) and Almaty both have assisted reproductive centers with international qualifications. Some institutions have established cooperative relationships with top IVF institutions in Russia and Israel, and their technical levels are reliable.
Legislative features:Surrogacy legislation in the United States is based on state units, and state laws vary significantly. "Surrogacy-friendly states" represented by California, Nevada, and Washington state not only allow commercial surrogacy, but also allow surrogacy before the child is born.forwardPre-Birth Order is one of the most legally protected surrogacy destinations in the world with pre-confirmation of parental rights through the court.
Main surrogacy friendly states:
Cost range:Usually priced at RMB 1.2-2 million, it is the most expensive option among major surrogacy destinations, but it also provides the highest level of medical technology, legal protection and transparency. Suitable for clients with extremely high security requirements and sufficient budget.
Special value to Chinese clients:Children born in the United States automatically obtain U.S. citizenship and can enter and exit the United States with a U.S. passport, providing children with long-term travel and residence convenience.
The following countries and regions have explicitly prohibited surrogacy (including commercial and altruistic) by legislation or judicial decisions, and surrogacy in these places may face criminal legal risks:
| Country/Region | Basis for prohibition | legal consequences |
|---|---|---|
| Chinese mainland | Relevant regulations of the former National Health and Family Planning Commission; "Measures for the Administration of Human Assisted Reproductive Technology" | The organization's license is revoked, and relevant personnel may bear administrative and criminal liability. |
| France | Article 16-7 of the Civil Code clearly stipulates that the surrogacy agreement is invalid | Contract is invalid, risk of criminal prosecution |
| Germany | Embryo Protection Act (1990) | Strictly prohibited and punishable by penalty |
| Spain | Article 10 of the Assisted Reproductive Technology Act | The surrogacy contract is invalid |
| Italy | The legislation was revised in 2004, and the ban will be further strengthened in 2024 (including the criminalization of overseas surrogacy) | Chinese citizens who go abroad for surrogacy may also face criminal prosecution |
| Thailand | After the implementation of the "Surrogacy Child Protection Law" in 2015, commercial surrogacy was completely closed to foreigners. | Foreign clients cannot legally complete surrogacy in Thailand |
| India | The Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021, allows altruistic surrogacy only for Indian citizens | Surrogacy is illegal for foreigners in India |
| Japan | There is no specific legislation, but the Japanese Society of Obstetrics and Gynecology explicitly prohibits members from participating in surrogacy. | It cannot be completed legally, and legal parental rights are highly uncertain. |
The United Kingdom commissioned the "Surrogacy Review Committee" to issue a report in 2023, recommending reform of the current legislation to allow surrogate mothers to obtain higher amounts of reasonable compensation and simplify the parental rights confirmation process. Although formal legislation has not yet been implemented, the direction is clear. Canada is also discussing whether to further relax restrictions on compensation for altruistic surrogacy.
As the surrogacy market expands, some originally relatively relaxed destinations have begun to tighten regulations. Both Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan have raised the qualification certification threshold for surrogacy agencies in the past two years and strengthened the review of documents of foreign clients. This is a positive signal for clients who choose formal institutions, but it also means that the living space of "pheasant" institutions is further compressed.
The Hague Conference on Private International Law (HCCH) continues to promote negotiations on a multilateral framework for "cross-border confirmation of international surrogacy parental rights". The draft recommendations released in 2023 propose a cross-border recognition mechanism for parental rights under the priority principle of "the best interests of the child", but it will take some time for countries to formally approve it. At present, the client still needs to rely on the local laws of the destination country and bilateral diplomatic channels to protect the child's legal status.
An increasing number of surrogacy-friendly countries are extending the scope of application to same-sex couples and single clients. Colombia and many states in the United States are at the forefront in this regard. However, it should be noted that this expansion trend is highly related to the overall social policy of the destination country and needs to be evaluated based on specific national conditions.
In its "Global Monitoring of Assisted Reproductive Technology" report released in 2020, the WHO did not make a positive or negative value judgment on surrogacy itself, but emphasized:
"Regardless of the nature of the surrogacy agreement, safeguarding the surrogate mother's physical and mental health, her right to informed consent, her right not to be exploited, and the best interests of the child born are core principles of any surrogacy regulatory framework."
WHO recommends that countries: When formulating or revising laws related to surrogacy, fully assess the health risks of surrogate mothers (including the risk of multiple ovulation inductions, multiple pregnancy complications, etc.) and establish an effective medical supervision mechanism.
IFFS pointed out in its 2023 Global Assisted Reproduction Regulatory Report that surrogacy practices vary significantly around the world and recommended that countries:
The IFFS report also pointed out that when surrogacy is carried out in countries with clear legislation, the rights and interests of the client and the surrogate mother can be better protected; on the contrary, when surrogacy is carried out in areas with vague laws, both parties face higher uncertain risks.
Before making a final decision on the surrogacy destination, it is recommended that the client check the following key issues one by one:
In 2026, the global surrogacy legal landscape will generally develop in a more standardized and transparent direction, but differences between countries are still significant. For Chinese families who need surrogacy, the following are core suggestions:
Kyrgyzstan, Georgia, Colombia, Kazakhstan, and the United States (friendly states) are currently the major legal surrogacy destinations in the world. These five options all have a relatively clear legal framework, and the differences lie in the scope of applicable people, cost range, medical level and geographical convenience.
Different countries have greatly different requirements for the identity of the client: heterosexual married couples have room for application in all legal destinations; single clients have relatively limited choices (Kyrgyzstan, Colombia, and some states in the United States are more friendly); the best choices for same-sex couples are concentrated in friendly states in the United States and Colombia.
The United States provides the highest level of legal protection and medical services, but the costs are also the highest. Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan have relatively complete protections, relatively reasonable costs, and are geographically closer to China. When choosing, "safety, legality, and transparency" should be the primary criteria, rather than simply pursuing low prices.
The legal complexity of surrogacy not only lies in the laws of the destination country, but also involves follow-up matters such as household registration, notarization, and determination of paternity in China. It is recommended that professional legal advisors accompany you throughout the entire surrogacy process to ensure legal compliance at every step.
Need to evaluate the most appropriate country and legal path to surrogacy based on your specific situation?
← Return to Knowledge Center | Free consultation with our professional consultants
References and authoritative sources:
The content of this article is for reference only and does not constitute legal advice. Please consult a licensed legal professional for specific applicable laws.